Dutchess County taxpayers who shelled out nearly a quarter-million dollars for a band shell in Bowdoin Park saw Peter Frampton, Kenny Loggins and the band America grace its stage after a 2005 unveiling.
Each annual concert in the Town of Poughkeepsie also featured the Hudson Valley Philharmonic and drew about 10,000 people.
Last year, the return that county taxpayers saw on the band shell did not involve numbers that were nearly as impressive.
According to the county, the band shell in 2013 was reserved 26 times for private events. At a cost of $75 per day, plus an added fee for a nonresident, that resulted in an earning of $1,975 for the year, the first in which the county rented out the band shell as a pavilion for private use.
So far for 2014, there are 18 reservations for the band shell as a pavilion. In addition to these band shell events, revenue was generated recently when the band shell, along with surrounding pavilions, were utilized for events that included a high school band performance and graduation ceremony. A pavilion at Bowdoin Park can be rented for $125 per day.
The county paid $236,000 for the band shell.
Demand for pavilions throughout Bowdoin Park has been so high that starting last year, the county Department of Public Works, which operates the park, began offering the band shell as an alternative to pavilions.
But the county's vision for the band shell as a venue to draw large crowds, along with the economic impact they can leave on a community, has not materialized. Beyond the cultural offerings, the arts in Dutchess County leave a multimillion-dollar impact through spending, income generated by spending and tax revenue.
"The vision hasn't matured and because of the economy and the public's expectation that we can't afford to take a direct financial loss, we've had to make use of that facility in other ways, until it becomes profitable again," Dutchess County Executive Marc Molinaro said. "I believe it will be profitable again."
The band shell serves as a reminder of how struggles with the economy continue, how this challenge can shape the arts, and how taxpayers can get caught in the middle.
"I think that's crazy," said Annette Simmons of the Town of Poughkeepsie, when told of the original plans for the band shell and how it is being used. "Aren't you wasting our money?"
The relationship between the arts, public facilities and the poor economy is also underscored by a stage in the City of Poughkeepsie's Waryas Park. The stage, which is used for community events and private gatherings, was utilized during the annual Hudson River Arts Festival, which over years drew thousands to the city's waterfront, but was canceled in 2009 because of the economy. Poughkeepsie Mayor John Tkazyik did not respond to a request by the Journal for data related to the cost of constructing the stage, how much it costs to rent and how often it gets used.
"Certainly, the end of the Bowdoin Park concerts and the arts festival were both directly related to the economic bust," said Chris Silva, executive director of the Bardavon 1869 Opera House in Poughkeepsie. The Bardavon coordinated the artistic end of the band shell concerts, helped design the stage at Waryas Park and, along with the city, staged the Hudson River Arts Festival. "They do kind of reflect the economy. There was an upswing and then a downswing and then there was no swing at all."
Molinaro, a county legislator when the band shell was built, said the county is working to draw arts and entertainment events that utilize the band shell, as at the hangar at Dutchess County Airport in Wappingers Falls; Dutchess Stadium in Fishkill, home to the minor league baseball Hudson Valley Renegades; and Wilcox Park in Milan.
"We are actively pursuing promoters and others who are interested in bringing arts and entertainment to any one of our venues," Molinaro said.
But, he continued, success "hinges on the economy."
John W. Barry: [email]jobarry@
poughkeepsiejournal.com[/email], 845-437-4822; Twitter: @JohnBarryPoJo
By the numbers
$236,000
Cost to construct Bowdoin Park band shell
10,000
Number of people who attended each of three concerts — America, Peter Frampton and Kenny Loggins — at the band shell after it opened in 2005
$1,975
Band shell earnings for 2013, excluding events that incorporated surrounding pavilions
26
Number of private events that utilized the band shell as a pavilion in 2013
State Treasurer and gubernatorial candidate Steven Grossman said the reversal by the American Gaming Association does not chill his interest in exploring online gaming to boost the state Lottery.
“They can have their squabbles out there all they want,” Grossman said. “We’ll continue to move forward … to study this issue and how it can potentially affect us, one way or another. Any smart business of any kind, public or private, would study that. You have to change to survive and flourish.”
The AGA announced this past week it would no longer push to expand online gaming into new states, an issue that has pitted opponents such as Sands chief Sheldon Adelson and Wynn Resorts head Steve Wynn against supporters such as MGM and Caesars Entertainment.
Grossman said the near $5 billion state Lottery still wants to explore if online gaming can help preserve its market share, so long as credit cards can’t be used to play and if it doesn’t increase gambling addiction or hurt Lottery retailers.
“I hear the differences of opinion out there,” Grossman said. “We’re not going to get dragged one way or another into that debate. We’ll simply study and be very careful with any approach to online gaming that doesn’t protect the people of this commonwealth appropriately.”
A bill is pending in the Legisla-ture that would clear the path for the Lottery to experiment with online gaming.
Adam Krejcik, managing director at Eilers Research, which tracks online gambling, said the AGA’s move dampened the prospects for new states jumping into the arena, particularly in the wake of poor returns in New Jersey.
“I think a state would much rather have the AGA support … someone needs to be leading the charge,” Krejcik said. “It’s hard to put a positive spin on it.”
Krejcik said online gaming revenue this year in New Jersey, where casinos run gambling sites, “will come in below the most conservative estimates out there,” about $140 million. Projections were as high as $1.2 billion, he said.
The state Gaming Commission — whose chairman, Stephen Crosby, called a forum in March to discuss online gambling, saying “the time is now” to discuss legalizing it — said the AGA decision does not change its posture.
“The AGA’s decision to withdraw from discussions regarding online gaming reinforces the commission’s position on this topic,” the commission said in a statement. “The commission believes that a slow and deliberate approach to this issue is the most responsible way to move forward given the significant varying opinions on this matter.”
Chips still on web gambling | Boston Herald