— A month after New York voters approved casino gambling and two weeks after New Jersey officials publicly opened online gambling, Pennsylvania lawmakers are looking to up the ante.
A Senate committee on Tuesday passed a resolution to have the Legislature study whether the state should legalize online gambling. The full Senate will vote on the resolution Wednesday.
Topics
Laws and Legislation
Casino and Gambling Industry
Gambling
See more topics »
The panel's unanimous vote comes nine years after the Race Horse Development and Gaming Act ushered casino gambling into Pennsylvania. Just last month, the law was expanded to allow wagering in local bars and social clubs.
The resolution doesn't dictate what sort of Internet-based games, such as poker or slots, the committee should consider adding when it completes its study by May 1. That date gives lawmakers, if they choose, time to work the plan into next year's budget proposal due for approval by July 1.
With the Legislature's Independent Fiscal Office projecting a two-year cumulative deficit of $839 million by June 2015, some lawmakers view online gambling as the ace the state needs to financially break even or come out ahead.
Other lawmakers see the nod to consider online gambling as Harrisburg's latest attempt to balance its books through wagering, this time from people's living rooms instead of at a casino, racetrack, local bar or social club.
Even with enough support, some form of online gambling would still be months — if not years — from becoming legal in Pennsylvania.
But one thing is certain: The Legislature's decision to consider online gambling will bring heated debate to the state Capitol — and stiff opposition from one of the world's richest men: Sheldon Adelson.
His company, Las Vegas Sands, owns Sands Casino Resort Bethlehem — arguably Pennsylvania's most successful gambling complex — and he hasn't been shy about voicing his disgust for online gambling.
Last month, Adelson hired an army of lawyers and lobbyists to press Congress for a federal ban on Internet gambling.
While critics say Adelson is just trying to protect his wealth, he contends there's no reliable way to prevent youths, substance abusers and addicted gamblers from gambling on the Internet — things that can at least be curbed in a casino where dealers and security officials are trained to stop underage gamblers and cut off drunken players.
Though Nevada has legalized online gambling, Adelson said his casinos will not take part for "moral" reasons.
He added that while online gambling might be a short-term boon to the casinos, in the long run it would cut into casino profits because some people would stop visiting casinos, costing thousands of casino jobs nationwide.
"No, online gambling is not a threat to my business," Adelson wrote in an opinion piece last month. "It's a threat to our society — a toxin which all good people ought to resist."
Whatever Adelson's motivation, Pennsylvania lawmakers can expect a visit from company officials or his newly formed Coalition to Stop Internet Gambling, Sands spokesman Ron Reese said Tuesday.
But plenty of other casino groups will be lobbying lawmakers to adopt online gambling. Online gambling opened Nov. 21 in New Jersey, and two of seven licenses issued so far are held by Caesars Entertainment, the same company that owns four casinos in New Jersey and Harrah's Casino in Chester.
Senate President Pro-Tem Joseph Scarnati, R-Jefferson, the prime sponsor of the resolution, said the state needs to find additional revenue because expenses are outpacing revenues, leaving no additional money for public education or universities.
But Scarnati said the main reason he wants the state to explore online gambling is that recent revenue reports show casino revenues flattening, maybe even falling, and those projections could get worse as competition grows in New York and New Jersey.
"If your revenues are not growing, they are staying stagnant. You are losing," Scarnati said.
Rep. Paul Clymer, R-Bucks, one of the Legislature's most vocal gambling opponents, said Adelson is correct to call online gambling a scourge. Congress' National Gambling Impact Study Commission Act of 1996 called Internet gambling the most addictive type of betting and led Congress to try banning it in 1999, Clymer said.
"We are all for making families stronger and we realize all the problems confronting the American family today, yet we are going [to consider] an addiction that causes irrevocable harm," Clymer said.
State Sen. Lisa Boscola, D-Northampton, whose district includes the Sands, said she sees both sides of the issue. She understands Adelson's concerns, both financially and morally, but sees the need to raise revenue as well. The ramifications are too great for the Senate to rush a decision, Boscola said.
"This is coming rather quickly," she said Tuesday. "I wish we'd slow down a little."
Sen. Robert "Tommy" Tomlinson, R-Bucks, whose district includes Parx Casino in Bensalem Township, said he previously opposed online gambling. But as more and more adults ages 21 to 31 gravitate to online sites to play poker, the state could be missing out on revenue.
Still, Tomlinson said, the Senate is not ready to pick which sort of online games to add without first talking to the casino industry and Pennsylvania Lottery. Those talks could be tricky, he said, because Sands is opposed to online gambling, Parx is on the fence and Harrah's may want full-fledged access now available in New Jersey.
"We have time to get it right," Tomlinson said. "We have until June."
Read more: Pa. Senate approves study to consider online gambling - mcall-com
Follow us: @mcall on Twitter | mcall.lv on Facebook
[url=
mcall-com/news/nationworld/pennsyl
The issue is definitely on their radar but the state doesn't seem to be in a rush to follow suit, according to State Rep. Richard Bennett, R-Long Beach, who's chairman of the House Gaming Committee. He said he doubts the Legislature will approve it in its 2014 session. He prefers to let Nevada, New Jersey and Delaware work out the kinks in their online gaming systems so Mississippi can learn from them.
We also agree that we can't sit back and watch others steal our cheese, and we agree that any Internet gambling should be tied to the existing casinos. Casino operators built the industry, and on the Coast they are a vital piece of our tourism pie. We expect the folks in Jackson will be eager to protect their interests because the state gets a chunk of casino taxes, too.
Another lawmaker, Democratic state Rep. Bobby Moak of Bogue Chitto, says next year he'll once again introduce online gambling legislation, saying it will give casinos and the treasury a boost. That could be true if it's done right. If not, it could just cannibalize the Coast's casino clientele.
Online gaming in this state seems inevitable. Morgan Stanley told Agence France-Presse it predicts online gambling revenue will hit $9.3 billion a year by 2020. It's not too early to start devising ways the state can share in that explosion of revenue. We urge the state to act not hastily, but not too conservatively either. We don't want some other state or nation encroaching on our gambling industry via the Internet.
What's bet in Mississippi should stay in Mississippi.
This editorial represents the views of the Sun Herald editorial board, which consists of President-Publisher Glen Nardi, Vice President and Executive Editor Stan Tiner, Vice President and Chief Financial Officer Flora S. Point, Audience and Human Resources Director Wanda Howell, Marketing and Interactive Director John McFarland and Associate Editor Tony Biffle. Opinions expressed by columnists, cartoonists and letter writers are their own.
Read more here: SUN HERALD | Editorial: Mississippi must keep an eye on online gambling | Editorials | The Sun Herald