Noel Edmonds's hit tea-time TV show Deal or No Deal may be forced to air after the 9pm watershed amid claims it constitutes gambling.
The Gambling Commission is expected to warn Channel 4 that the programme could be breaking the law because it does not involve an element of skill. Non-skill games played for profit require a gambling licence.
ITV's Red Or Black?, presented by Ant and Dec and developed by Simon Cowell, is also said to be under investigation.
The shows could be subjected to tight restrictions on the type of advertising broadcast during breaks and the amount of pre-broadcast publicity.
They could even be forced to obtain a licence costing £60,000, and £30,000 to renew every year.
Meanwhile ITV plans to revive Bruce Forsyth’s perennial hit Play Your Cards Right have also been put on ice pending the outcome of the probe.
It is against the law to run non-skill games for money without a gambling licence – raising the extraordinary prospect of producers being jailed if they defy the warning. Channel 4 may then decide it would be simpler to cancel Deal Or No Deal, than be constrained by so many restrictions.
The programme, which has been presented by Edmonds since it was first broadcast in 2005, regularly attracts an audience of more than four million in its afternoon slot.
Viewers watch as contestants guess which of 22 identical sealed boxes contains the show’s elusive jackpot in what programme makers Endemol say is a contest of ‘instinct, gut feeling and luck’.
As boxes are opened, contestants decide whether to accept a cash offer from the mysterious Banker, or play on in the hope of increasing the offer, while running the risk of receiving a much lower prize.
However, a Government source told The Mail on Sunday: ‘The Gambling Commission does not seem to think that there is any skill element to the show.
‘Even though at the beginning of the show, contestants do not have to stake any of their own money, the argument is that once they’ve picked a box, which could contain a lot of cash, in subsequent rounds they are in effect gambling with their own money,’
Separately, the Commission is also understood to have raised issues over Red Or Black?, where contestants win £1 million on the spin of a wheel.
The Commission has told the programme makers that the participants need to show more skill in winning the top prize to escape the need for a gaming licence – which would mean the end of the crucial roulette wheel. Regulators are also said to be concerned about the way the show ‘glamorises’ gambling.
The Mail on Sunday also understands that ITV is shelving plans to bring back the popular Eighties quiz show Play Your Cards Right, in which prizes are determined on the turn of a card, for the same reason.
Last night the move was met with bewilderment among game show bosses, who argue that rules created to control casinos and illegal betting should not be applied to entertainment programmes.
One senior broadcasting source, who has been fighting the probe behind the scenes, said: ‘This is an absolutely ridiculous state of affairs.
‘The Gambling Commission has no right to be poking its nose into what are harmless television programmes.
'How can anyone regard Deal Or No Deal as gambling?
'It is probably the most innocent show on television. I think its very telling that this programme is aired in 30 different countries but only in Britain has this become an issue.
‘You also have to look it from the point of broadcaster. They are already heavily regulated by Ofcom. Why on earth would they want to also come under the control of the Gambling Commission as well?
That means they would be answerable to two different regulators who would be looking into its affairs. The people who make Deal Or No Deal want to operate as a television production company not a casino.’
Simon Cowell’s spokesman, Max Clifford, said: ‘Simon wants to come up with the most exciting combination he can which remains within the rules. His view is that it is a light entertainment programme with a gambling element – not what the Commission is claiming.’
As well as restrictions on scheduling, advertising and trailers, any TV company whose shows fell under gambling rules would also need to prove to the Commission that its executives had an understanding of the complex laws and regulations surrounding the betting industry. This could force them to team up with a gambling company in order to employ the relevant expertise.
The expert said: ‘The gambling industry is the most stringently regulated industry in the UK because of the capacity for high level organised crime.
‘The Gambling Commission wants to make sure these shows are not enticing people to go out and gamble recklessly, and some programmes may fall into this category in their current format.
‘If a TV company was unwilling to change the format then they could be forced into a range of moves which would effectively kill off the show altogether.
‘The problem is this is an extremely complex area that is in danger of encroaching on harmless family entertainment. It will undoubtedly be a case of compromise for the shows in question, but if the Commission aren’t careful, we could see the end of several popular family game shows.’
A spokesman for the Gambling Commission refused to comment, saying it never talks about ‘individual’ cases.
However, he confirmed that the Commission was about to publish new guidance for television game shows.
He said: ‘In the first instance, we would contact the operator to discuss the situation, as compliance is always preferable over enforcement action.’
The Commission, which was set up as the independent regulator under the Gambling Act 2005, is required to keeping crime out of gambling, ensure gambling is conducted fairly and openly and protect children and vulnerable people from being harmed or exploited by gambling.
The spokesman declined to say how much
Registered: 2006/12/07 Posts: 0
I'm a reporter with Village Voice media, a chain of weekly newspapers across the country. We're doing an in-depth story on military veterans and active-duty service members who have fallen prey to gambling addictions. Recent studies have shown that gambling addiction affects veterans at twice the rate of civilians. I'm trying to reach out to men and women from all branches of the military who've developed a gambling addiction and might be willing to share their stories with us. They're free to speak to me either on the record, or under the strict agreement that their names not be published.
Those people interested in speaking to me may email me at [email]john.tucker@riverfronttimes.com[/email] to set up a time to talk, or just call me at 314-754-6414. We think this is an important story about the brave men and women who serve our country.
John H. Tucker