As California considers a major expansion of legalized gambling, Gov. Jerry Brown wants to revamp how the state regulates the industry and protects its millions of customers.
Brown’s January budget plan includes a proposal to consolidate parts of the California Gambling Control Commission, which is autonomous, with the state Department of Justice, which is overseen by Attorney General Kamala Harris.
Little is known about what the governor has in mind beyond a two-sentence description in last month’s budget that criticized a “bifurcated system of gambling control” and describes a goal of “consolidating support, investigatory, and compliance functions” within the Justice Department. The proposal, unlike other parts of the January package, has not been fleshed out in bill form.
“We’re not really sure what the plan is. We saw the paragraph in the budget and we’ve made inquiries,” said gambling commission Chairwoman Stephanie Shimazu. “The commission would still exist, but to what extent, we don’t know.”
Lynda Gledhill, a spokeswoman for Harris, said the attorney general’s office has not received any details of Brown’s plan.
Brown spokesman Evan Westrup said the commission would remain a stand-alone entity. Much of its staff, however, would become part of the Justice Department’s Bureau of Gambling Control.
Gambling regulation would not suffer, he said.
“One of the reasons that the staff is being incorporated into the bureau is because the bureau has special agents who have expanded authority to engage in investigations and enforcement activities,” Westrup said.
California is one of 48 states that have at least one type of legal gambling. Gambling in card clubs and at horse tracks has been legal for generations.
In 1984, voters approved a state lottery. And in 2000, voters legalized Las Vegas-style gambling on tribal land. Legislation to legalize online gambling in California is expected to be introduced soon in the Legislature.
Casinos, card clubs and other gambling businesses have a large Capitol lobbying presence and spend heavily on campaign contributions to state lawmakers.
A jumble of different state agencies regulates the industry. Besides the gambling control commission and Department of Justice, there is the state lottery commission, the state Horse Racing Board, the Office of Problem Gambling in the Department of Alcohol and Drug Programs, and the governor’s office.
Shared duties
Among other duties, the Department of Justice and the gambling control commission share regulation of Las Vegas-style gambling on tribal land. The commission has 70 employees. The Bureau of Gambling Control has 160 employees inside the Department of Justice.
Brown’s proposal, which would not change the other agencies, is the first time any leader has called for revamping the state’s gambling oversight. Even former Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger’s California Performance Review, the sweeping 2004 report on overhauling government, left the subject untouched.
Brown has first-hand knowledge of the issue. He has appointed three members of the gambling commission and designated Shimazu as chairwoman. He was attorney general from 2006 to 2010 and his top adviser on gambling-related issues, Jacob Appelsmith, formerly was chief of the Bureau of Gambling Control.
Cheryl Schmidt of Stand Up California, a longtime gambling watchdog group, said she is unsure about the governor’s proposal and wants to see more details.
She once had high hopes that the commission would be an effective forum for public concerns about gambling. She has been disappointed, she said.
Skepticism about the commission also comes from some of the entities it regulates. Some gaming tribes, for example, have had chilly relations with the agency.
Jack Duran, an attorney with many tribal clients, said he thinks the state Justice Department should take the lead role to regulate gambling in California.
“I think it has a good collaborative relationship with the tribes,” said Duran, who also is a Placer County supervisor. “Unfortunately, I think the gambling control commission looks at things a little bit differently.”
Duran cited the commission’s recent efforts to impose casino rules and procedures to protect patrons and tribal members after a court ruling revoked a federal agency’s power to do the same. The years-long push angered some tribes, whose leaders felt they already had adequate safeguards in place.
The Bureau of Gambling Control brokered the final deal, Duran said. “That was a situation that could have gotten really ugly,” he said.
Concerns expressed
But others spoke highly of the commission. They worried that Brown’s proposal could set back the regulatory relationship between the state, tribes, and card clubs.
George Forman, an attorney for the Morongo Band of Mission Indians near Banning, said the commission finally has knowledgeable membership and staff.
“It would be unfortunate if this group of commissioners were to be rendered obsolete, particularly so soon after they have become fully functional,” Forman said in an email.
A potentially worthwhile goal, he said, would be to model California’s system of gambling oversight on Nevada. There, a gaming commission acts on the recommendations of a gaming control board, which conducts audits, enforcement and other activities.
Registered: 2006/12/07 Posts: 0
A small, bipartisan group of lawmakers this week introduced legislation, which if passed by a supermajority of legislators would go to voters as a November ballot referendum. The bill would allow up to five casinos to be established at existing racetracks, as well as two additional casinos that would not be located within 60 miles of current tracks. “Opponents of expanded gaming should not deny their fellow citizens the right to vote on this issue,” Beshear, a Democrat, said in his weekly video address. “Kentuckians deserve the chance to have their votes counted in this decision.”
State Rep. Jim DeCesare, R-Bowling Green, said he’s already heard from several constituents. Of the 57 calls he received this week regarding the legislation, 53 callers were opposed to either gambling or to putting the matter up to a vote. The other four constituents said they wanted the opportunity to vote.
DeCesare said he hasn’t had an opportunity to review the legislation because it’s currently waiting to be heard in committee, which is expected to happen next week.
DeCesare said he is generally against expanded gaming, but also said there might be a time when the only way to put the issue to rest is by letting voters have their say.
“We’ll see what happens in the Senate,” DeCesare said. “My gut is that even if it gets out of the Senate, it will have a real tough time in the House.”
Three-fifths of House members and three-fifths of Senate members must vote in favor of the bill before the constitutional amendment question can go before the voters.
“We propose to give Kentucky voters the opportunity to allow similar types of expanded gaming in our commonwealth and keep that money inside our borders,” Beshear said.
State Sen. Mike Wilson, R-Bowling Green, said he remains firm in his stance against casino gaming. Asked whether seven casinos is too many, Wilson said, “One is too many.”
Beshear said casino gaming would allow “Kentucky entertainment dollars” to remain in Kentucky. He said potential tax revenues are being spent on gaming in surrounding states.
“This money funds their schools, their libraries, their police departments and other improvements,” Beshear said.
Beshear said Kentucky runs the risk of taking steps backward in areas such as education, public protection and job creation if casino gaming fails to be approved.
“The proposed state budget is bleak, thanks to a sagging national economy and slow-to-recover state revenues,” Beshear said. “And until our state generates more revenue, we will always fall behind.”
Wilson said, based on conversations he’s had with lawmakers, that some had been considering voting in favor of the measure, but now seem to be changing their minds. Because of the restrictions on where the casinos can be located, Wilson said some legislators feel the measure would put their home communities out of possibility getting a casino, so they’re not in favor of the bill.