Florida's gambling laws, thanks in part to special interest influence, are a hodgepodge that savvy attorneys have learned to exploit.
By Michael Vasquez
As Florida considers ushering in a new era of casino mega-resorts, a dispute in the tiny Panhandle town of Gretna has focused attention on the state’s existing gambling landscape — and the considerable confusion that surrounds it.
Florida’s current gambling laws, some say, are so haphazard, so disjointed, that no one can even agree on what the term “horse racing” means anymore.
If you’re thinking of the Kentucky Derby, think again. Gretna’s new Creek Entertainment barrel racing facility — which also will offer poker and hopes to add slots — has just opened, despite fervent opposition from the state’s horse trainers and breeders. Instead of racing around an oval track, these horses zig-zag around red barrels, rodeo-style.
The owners of Creek Entertainment — which include a savvy Gulfstream Park lobbyist who once tried to install slots at Miami International Airport — say the particulars of how the horses are running don’t matter. Florida’s Department of Business and Professional Regulation has agreed, and signed off on barrel racing as fully compliant with Creek Entertainment’s quarter horse racing permits.
By opting for unconventional barrel races, Creek Entertainment is poised to reap all the rewards of running a horse track, while avoiding the typical requirement of sharing profits with the horsemen.
“This is nothing more than a get-rich-quick scheme,” said Kent Stirling, executive director of the Florida Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association. “When this gets to court, they’re going to have a lot of questions to answer.”
Stirling and other horsemen are working to get a hearing before an administrative law judge, and the legal tussle will likely continue after that. Attorney Marc Dunbar, a Gulfstream Park lobbyist with an ownership stake in Creek Entertainment, says the dispute over his new track boils down to greedy horsemen who are unwilling to share racing purses with barrel racing riders. As for the notion that barrel racing isn’t true horse racing, Dunbar is incredulous.
“First of all, why is it called barrel racing?” Dunbar asked.
Of late, Dunbar has not only had to justify barrel racing, but he’s also been put on the defensive by accusations that influence-peddling played a role in the state approval of his racetrack. When Jim Barnes, a former investigator with the state’s Division of Pari-Mutuel Wagering, retired last month, his farewell email to colleagues said he was joining the “dark side” and taking a job as head of security at the new barrel racing track. Dunbar insists that Barnes has not been hired and never even filled out an application.
When reached by a reporter, Barnes’ only comment was, “I really hope you don’t screw up my retirement job.”
These days, as horse racing fades in popularity but slot machines and poker generate huge profits, horse racing permits can be lucrative not because of the actual races but because, under Florida law, running horses entitles the permit holder to offer poker and sometimes slots. The same is true of jai-alai permits, which can allow casinos so long as the permit holder stages an even-less-popular gambling sport that features acrobatic men bouncing a ball off a wall.
The owners of Miami’s Flagler Dog Track/Magic City Casino recently obtained a summer jai-alai permit using a 30-year-old loophole in state gambling laws. The new permit allows construction of a new casino/jai-alai fronton anywhere in Miami-Dade County. Even if no one shows up to bet on jai-alai, the casino could post a heavy profit through poker and slots. For now, Flagler’s owners have yet to unveil any concrete plans for what they might do with the new permit.
In Broward, influential developer Ron Bergeron is pursuing a jai-alai permit, with the possibility of building a facility in Weston. Bergeron’s attorney in that jai-alai bid is David Romanik, a Florida gambling law expert who also has a stake in Gretna’s barrel racing operation. The state’s gambling laws, he said, are the result of decades of lobbyist influence — a dog track or horse track, looking to boost the bottom line, will convince a lawmaker to insert a beneficial clause or two.
The frequent goal, Romanik said, is to reward just one particular company, but writing specialized laws like that is unconstitutional. So the law is broadened just a touch, making it conceivable, but perhaps unlikely, that the new law could apply to someone else.
But that kind of legal wording can lead to legal loopholes big enough for attorneys in the know to exploit later on, Romanik said.
“The statutes are published, so they’re available for anyone to read,” Romanik said. But, he added, “I think you have to have specialized knowledge to be able to connect the dots.”
The notion of insider attorneys driving Florida’s gambling policy strikes state Sen. Ellyn Bogdanoff as all wrong. Bogdanoff, a Fort Lauderdale Republican, is sponsoring a bill in the Legislature this year that would allow three large-scale “destination” casinos to open in South Florida. Though disagreements over the wisdom of allowing more casinos has dominated the public debate so far, Bogdanoff’s bill would also set up a statewide gaming commission that could, in theory, replace Florida’s hodgepodge of gambling laws with clear, understandable rules of the road.
The current slew of loophole-exploiting gambling proposals proves an legal overhaul is necessary, Bogdanoff told a gathering of Broward business leaders last week.
“I couldn’t have written the script better myself,” Bogdanoff said.
Why couldn’t Florida’s gambling guidelines be updated without approving new casinos? Bogdanoff says she’s tried a stand-alone regulation bill in the past and it got nowhere in the Legislature. But this time, the three casinos’ provision could end up killing t
Registered: 2006/12/07 Posts: 0
First of all, internet wagering on the horse races has never been outlawed by the government and it is legal in states that allow it. A company called TVG is one of several companies offering traditional pari-mutuel betting on horse racing in states where it's legal. TVG was acquired in 2009 by BetFair, a London UK online gambling firm. To that end BetFair, recently opened a technical hub which employs about 75 people in San Francisco, California. The firm is planning to release a product in May that could not only transform betting on the horse races but could also save the declining fortunes of the U.S. horse racing industry.
BetFair which claims an annual global revenue of just over $500 million has developed the exchange concept of betting, in which online gamblers place bets against one another. As an example if a punter wants to bet on a particular horse to win and another bettor thinks that particular horse won't finish first, BetFair will broker the bet and take a commission.
Exchange betting has not yet been authorized in California, but a law passed last year will make it legal starting in May, which, is when BetFair plans to open its online exchange.
Not only does BetFair let racing fans bet against one another, it allows them to bet in ways they can't with traditional wagering.
Stephen Burn, Head of BetFair's San Francisco office, comments, "You can keep betting in the middle of a race," Burn continued to explain, betting can continue until the results are posted, so "if there's a photo finish, you can keep betting until a result is announced."
Whether or not the advent of exchange betting will save the horse racing industry, remains to be seen. Stay posted.