With the Legislature set to consider allowing Vegas-style casinos, even as smaller operators seek a rash of new pari-mutuel permits, Florida finds itself at a gambling crossroads.
The state could explode with more gambling options, from glitzy, high-end resorts in South Florida that offer slots, card games and craps to barrel racing — and maybe slot machines — in areas such as tiny Gadsden County in Florida's Panhandle. Or the courts, now considering several lawsuits challenging gambling expansion, could force all the new projects back to the drawing board. "This obviously has a lot of moving pieces to it," said Rep. Scott Plakon, R-Longwood, who opposes gambling expansion efforts.
Last month, Sen. Ellyn Bogdanoff, R-Fort Lauderdale, and Rep. Erik Fresen, R-Miami, unveiled legislation that would bring three "destination casino" resorts to the state. At about the same time, the state approved a license for betting on barrel racing in the tiny city of Gretna, and the county put a referendum on the ballot that could allow slot machines at the facility as well.
Then, a lawyer for Magic City Casino in Miami found a loophole in the law that he said would allow it to get a license for summer jai alai; another attorney wants to exploit the same loophole to put jai alai in Weston. And most recently, the owners of Hamilton Downs, a jai alai and poker room in Jasper in north Florida, also filed for a barrel-racing permit for their quarter-horse track.
Finally, Internet cafes — offering "sweepstakes" that critics say are akin to slot machines — are continuing to pop up in strip malls all over the state.
For Bogdanoff, this explosion of gambling is reason enough to pass her bill — to get control of the industry through a new state gambling commission. Bogdanoff said she wants to create a "strategic vision" that starts with high-end resorts — and then decide how these facilities fit that vision: Seminole Indian casinos; slot-machine "racinos"; pari-mutuel tracks, frontons and poker rooms; and Internet cafes.
"We have to decide they're here. Do we protect them? Do we give them parity? Do we want to continue to expand through clever lawyering? Or do we want to say, 'This is it, this is the strategic vision: up to three destination gaming resorts,' " she said last week.
"Let the gaming commission make the decisions on the nitty-gritty, how it gets done. But we don't want any more Internet cafes; we don't want any other counties expanding," she said.
For the backers of destination resorts and the smaller gambling venues, the expressed motivation is the same: jobs.
In Gretna, plans are under way to hire 178 people, a significant amount in a city of about 1,700 people that is poor and largely black.
"For us, this is just the tip of the iceberg," said Clarence Jackson, mayor of Gretna. "We're sure that we'll have some opportunities. The main thing for people around here, they're looking for jobs."
Casino executives from Las Vegas and Asia are making the same promises using bigger numbers: up to 100,000 if three megaresort-casinos open in Miami-Dade and Broward counties. Plus, they say, they'll attract millions of new tourists who will shop at local restaurants and travel to other Florida destinations such as Disney World.
"The potential here is exciting," said Jessica Hoppe, general counsel for Genting, which has spent more than $300 million for bay-front property in Miami to build a $3.8 billion resort, including the world's largest casino.
But the Florida Supreme Court — and the Legislature — could bring all these plans to a screeching halt.
Last week, owners of Miami Jai Alai and Calder Casino and Race Course asked the court to hear their appeal of a judicial decision allowing Hialeah Park racetrack to open a racino. More significantly, they're also challenging whether the Legislature has the authority to expand gambling or whether expansion requires a statewide constitutional amendment.
They argue that a 2004 referendum allowing slots in Miami-Dade and Broward applied only to pari-mutuels that were open at the time; Hialeah was closed. But in 2009, legislators authorized slots at Hialeah, and in 2010 a Leon County circuit judge said the Legislature could allow gambling anywhere in the state.
The case is crucial to the destination-casino bill. If the Supreme Court were to side with Calder, it would mean casino executives would need a constitutional amendment — passed by 60 percent of voters — to go forward. Three attempts in the past 33 years to pass such an amendment have failed.
If a statewide referendum were required, said Las Vegas Sands lobbyist Nick Iarossi, the company would "probably take our ball and go home" rather than wage an expensive campaign that had a high probability of failing.
Gretna's facility has also drawn a legal challenge from critics who say wagering barrel racing — normally a rodeo contest, not a betting event — was never authorized by the Legislature and therefore can't be permitted by the Department of Business and Professional Regulation.
In December, an administrative-law judge is set to hear a challenge by the Quarter Horse Racing Association, which called barrel racing an "entirely new form of activity never before authorized or approved for pari-mutuel wagering in this state."
Dan Adkins, vice president of Hollywood's Mardi Gras Casino, called the Gretna plan a "scam."
"All of this is patently illegal," he said.
The Legislature is watching the court cases but will move forward with destination-casino discussion. A full Senate vote is expected in mid- to late January.
But Bogdanoff admitted that the Legislature has shied for decades from making big changes to the gambling industry and might not agree this year.
"I don't know that the bill passes," she said. "That's why we're having the discussion."
Registered: 2006/12/07 Posts: 0
There appears to be a number of very large member states who jealously guard their gambling business – in particular online, against any encroachment by foreign operators. Ostensibly these Governments don’t want to ‘let go’ of monopolistic gambling policies – often supposedly in place to protect the public, when nothing could be more obviously further from the truth. Gambling and online gambling is massive revenue boosting business, and it has become blatant that certain EU states function under circumstances of double standards. The EU marketplace has strict free-market policies.
The Remote Gambling Association, (The RGA represents most of the world’s largest licensed, and stock market-listed remote gambling companies and provides the industry with a single voice on all the issues of importance to regulators, legislators, and key decision makers around the world.) is understandably full of praise for the new resolution. It certainly offers a refreshing outlook for many licensed online gambling private sector operators; guaranteeing compliance with EU laws. Clive Hawkswood – CEO of the RGA said ~ ‘The European Parliament’s resolution demonstrates a marked change in approach. It now wants to regulate rather than prohibit; and it is pressing the Commission to act against Member States which do no comply.’
The resolution makes it clear regarding the duties of the European Commission to act when member states violate the ‘freedoms’ entrenched in EU treaties. In a recent European Court of Justice Landmark decision, Italy was taken to tasks after refusing a license to operate an online gambling site to a British company. Theirs is a newly regulated industry, and their refusal was seen in a very bad light by EU courts.