Batam, a city which thrives on tourism, is finding itself in a fix over what is proving to be a money-spinner with tourists, but goes against religious beliefs of this predominantly Muslim nation.
In recent weeks, special anti-gambling squads from the Indonesian police have descended on Batam, raiding and shutting down more than 70 covert gambling arcades filled with gaming machines, and arresting dozens of people.
These arcades, known in Indonesia as "gelpers", masquerade as sports arcades and are a big draw for tourists.
National police senior spokesman Anton Bachrul Alam said police stepped up enforcement on these illegal operations in Batam after increased complaints against them by local residents.
Indonesia, where more than 85 per cent of the country is Muslim, bans gambling because Islam does not allow it. But with other countries in the region benefiting economically from gaming, it is facing pressure from two of its more touristy cities - Batam and Bintan - to give some concession on this blanket ban.
Several years ago, the local Bintan government presented a detailed plan to build an integrated resort with a casino on the island. But after months of debate, the plan did not get the nod because lawmakers in Jakarta shot it down due to religious reasons.
The recent crackdown on gelpers in Batam has reignited the debate.
The head of Batam's tourism agency, Yusfa Hendri, said gelpers are a main tourist attraction in his city, which attracted more than 900,000 tourists last year. "The presence of gelpers has especially boosted the tourism industry, and indeed provided jobs," he said in an SMS message to The Straits Times.
But Inspector General Anton was firm in his response on that: "Gelper is a form of gambling, although the local government lets them operate. We hope these operations end."
He also promised more raids on such illegal gaming activities.
Sociologist Adrianus Meliala from the University of Indonesia said there have been calls by academics, tourism industry players and other citizens to amend Indonesia's law on gambling, accommodating at least restricted operations such as casinos which allow only foreigners in.
Another option being discussed is having a casino on an island, which would help to restrict who can gain entry.
"A law should reflect the reality on the ground," Professor Adrianus told The Straits Times, adding that there are aspirations from some quarters to legalize gambling. "A law should adjust to the current reality."
Bagus Sudibya of the Association of Indonesian Tours and Travel Agencies told The Straits Times: "It's a difficult decision, but do we want to continue seeing thousands of Indonesians spend money on gambling overseas? That is capital flight. So it's high time the government did something."
Batam and Bintan are not the only Indonesian cities where covert gambling is rampant. Big cities like Jakarta have seen illegal gambling activities, mainly catering to Chinese Indonesians who see it as part of the culture and entertainment.
"Covert gambling operations are organized by certain entrepreneurs who allegedly get backing from rogue senior police or military officers," Musni Umar, a sociologist at Syarif Hidayatullah State Islamic University in Jakarta, told The Straits Times.
Economically speaking, allowing gambling to restricted people could be considered, said Musni. But he doubts that Indonesia would do it because none of the political parties would dare support gambling as the majority of the population are opposed to it.
"They are afraid of losing in the elections if they ever come out and say they support gambling," he said.
Musni agrees that gambling should be allowed in Indonesia as long as there are tight restrictions banning Muslims from entering the casinos. "Or else, Indonesians with enough money would go to Singapore or Malaysia to play there anyway."
Registered: 2006/12/07 Posts: 0
The governor remained tight-lipped about what exactly he wants from lawmakers, who approved the gambling bill at the end of May but won't send it to Quinn out of fear he'll veto it. Quinn said he plans to "lay out principles, I think, that will be good for the Legislature to listen to." Lawmakers return to Springfield at the end of the month for fall session. Sponsors have said they are willing to work on a compromise, but say that's difficult without specifics from Quinn.
As passed, the gambling bill would allow new casinos in Chicago, southern Cook County, Lake County, Rockford and Danville. It would also authorize slot machines at racetracks and nearly year-round horse racing and gambling at the state fairgrounds in Springfield. All told, the number of gambling positions in Illinois would jump from 12,000 to 39,000.
Senate President John Cullerton, D-Chicago, has said that lawmakers can reduce the number of gambling positions without eliminating any of the five new casinos.
On Wednesday, Quinn said the number of gambling spots needs to be lowered, but he also expressed concerns that increasing the overall number of casinos would cause them to draw business away from one another. Cullerton, however, has argued the locations designated in the bill were picked to stop gamblers from crossing state lines to place bets, and not compete with other Illinois casinos.
Still, Quinn said other major changes must be made to the gambling bill, including shoring up oversight and ensuring enough money is set aside for education. Quinn contends the legislation would give major tax breaks to a Chicago casino when that money should instead be funneled into schools.
"The whole idea of this gambling, whether it's the lottery or casino gambling, is to help some good cause," Quinn said. "And the cause I think all of us believe in is education, and I don't feel the bill that I read through over the last several months properly invests in education in Illinois."