Our gambling laws make about as much sense as the government banning gin, but not vodka, during Prohibition.
Some laws allow gambling, some encourage it, and some ban it. You can run an online business for people to bet on horse races, but not on a poker hand. So instead of collecting taxes on the $30 billion that is bet in this country every year on online poker sites run by offshore companies, our government is investing tax dollars in an attempt to close down the games. It's time to fix this absurd system.
While our nation's leaders fret over our debt, there are millions of American poker players willing to throw coins into tax coffers in order to test their skills. But the national love for Texas Hold 'Em brings in no taxes while our prosecutors pursue the dealers.
On April 15, a day the online poker world dubbed Black Friday, the Justice Department unsealed indictments against 11 players in the online poker world, including the founders of popular sites PokerStars, Full Tilt Poker and Absolute Poker. The government also, at least temporarily, seized and shut down the websites. Using the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act, a law passed in 2006 but steeped in archaic concepts of virtue, the feds are looking to convict these defendants and reap forfeitures of some $3 billion.
To identify those forfeited dollars, prosecutors had to build a complex case based on how people paid to play, including securing restraining orders on 75 bank accounts. Now, they will have to prove these 11 defendants guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. This complicated and greedy grab by the Justice Department is totally unnecessary.
The government is spending millions of dollars on the chance of raking in $3 billion. Who is gambling now? Why not instead collect a steady stream of tax dollars on online poker, like many other countries do every day?
Because our laws now make some online gambling legal and other online gambling illegal, we have a likely unconstitutional Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act. We also have to appease leaders in other World Trade Organization member countries who are miffed at our illogical and shortsighted law that violates the treaty in spirit and has ensnared offshore companies that run online poker sites. It is likely that WTO countries will come after the U.S. again for the April 15 roundup.
We need not make this a no-limit game. The estimated 2.5 million Americans who play online poker know there is some skill to the game, unlike other sports that can be rigged. There can be online safeguards built in to stop underage players and to warn and screen for problem gamblers, just like casinos do on a regular basis.
We don't need more charges of bank fraud and money laundering against poker companies. Instead, we need to end this madness with a solid challenge to the constitutionality of the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act, which is aimed at preventing financial services firms from processing funds for online gambling. It's worth noting that Congress hasn't targeted the online poker players in this country, where lawmakers know full well its popularity.
Forbes has reported that in 2009, online poker took in revenue of about $1.4 billion in the U.S. with PokerStars and Full Tilt, whose founders are now indicted, bringing in about 70 percent of the total. Let's stop taking a double hit here. Stop spending to prosecute under an inconsistent law and start taxing online poker sites under the proven model used by other countries.
The current poker prosecution echoes "the Noble Experiment" of Prohibition. It is an attempt to enforce a morality that average citizens don't find immoral. Just as the 18th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution begat the 21st Amendment to repeal it, if Congress won't legalize online poker, we should go all in and let the U.S. Supreme Court take a good look at this cockeyed prosecutorial tool.
Flood is a Houston-based white-collar defense attorney and former prosecutor who represented the owner of
BetonSports.com in what was the largest online gambling case in U.S. history until last month.
This month's federal indictments of three prominent online poker outfits threw the multibillion-dollar industry into turmoil.
The charges could create a window of opportunity for California or other states to legalize online games. Or they may give state lawmakers another reason to keep a safe distance from the issue.
Even before the charges, licensing online gambling has divided politically active tribes with casinos as well as veteran members of the Legislature's Democratic majority. The Morongo Band of Mission Indians near Banning and the San Manuel Band of Mission Indians near San Bernardino are dominant members of a group pushing one of two legalization bills in Sacramento.
But other influential tribes, such as the Pechanga Band of Luiseno Indians near Temecula, have been vocal critics of the idea, saying it would hurt tribal casinos. And other tribes, such as the Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians in the Coachella Valley, have stayed neutral.
Supporters of legalizing online gambling say California is losing out on hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue from residents playing illegal sites based in Ireland, the Isle of Man and elsewhere. Legalization at the federal level is inevitable, they say, and California would get the most money if it had its own system in place before then.
But skeptics downplay the prospect of quick action in Washington. They also contend that legalizing online poker or other games, such as California 21, could violate parts of revenue-sharing agreements between the state and tribes. And legal online games would increase the number of problem gamblers, critics say.
And among proponents of online gambling, there are deep divisions about the right approach. State senators Lou Correa, D-Santa Ana, and Rod Wright, D-Los Angeles, have dueling measures.
Senate leader Darrell Steinberg, D-Sacramento, recently told colleagues that his office will try to help broker a consensus.
"Obviously, if you have divisions, particularly among Indian tribes, that makes it tough," said Assemblyman Brian Nestande, R-Palm Desert , the top Republican on the Assembly committee that oversees gambling. "And you're always going to have some people who believe you shouldn't have any legalized gaming at all."
Nestande has not taken a position on either bill.
FEDERAL CHARGES
The indictments of Full Tilt Poker, Poker Starz and Absolute Poker on April 15 -- what some industry insiders call "Black Friday" -- injected a new level of uncertainty into the California debate.
U.S. authorities allege that the companies, which are based outside the U.S., set up phony businesses to move money to and from U.S. players as a way to bypass the 2006 federal ban on online gambling. The feds seized domain names, and thousands of U.S. players lost access to their money, at least temporarily.
The indictments leave untouched a provision of the federal law that allows states to license their own online games. California would be the first to legalize.
People closely involved in the process disagree on how the latest developments change the chances of legalization.
"In my opinion, this indictment is really going to put a damper on anything happening in Sacramento, and nationally, for that matter," said Jerome Encinas, director of government affairs for the California Nations Indian Gaming Association.
But within hours of the indictments, the group behind the Morongo-backed legislation said it was the perfect time to act.
"By enacting SB 40, sites like those indicted today would be banned from the California market and strong protections for consumers would be in place," said Ryan Hightower, spokesman for the California Online Poker Association. "This is a real game-changer in terms of revenue potential for California."
Patrick Dorinson, a spokesman for several online poker firms that have never taken illegal U.S. bets, said the indictments should eliminate fears that large off-shore sites would swoop in and dominate a legalized California market.
"There's a window that's open now," Dorinson said. "You've now got 6 million people in the country, and 1 million people in California, with no place to play."
TWO BILLS IN PLAY
The issue has attracted a bevy of special interests, including card clubs, the horse-racing industry, software vendors and tribes.
The Correa bill backed by the Morongo tribe originally would have put a single "licensed entity" that was a tribe or already had a gambling license in charge of a legalized online poker network.
Last month, Correa amended the measure to allow three licensed entities at the start, to a maximum of five. The change hasn't ended criticism that the bill's influential backers are trying to limit competition.
"Other than the fact it's illegal, it might be a good idea," Wright said.
Wright leads the committee that oversees gambling issues. Correa's bill faces a May 6 deadline to be considered by the panel and, as of Wednesday, no hearing had been set.
Wright's bill, three times as long, would license games besides poker. He also wants to expand the pool of potential licensees beyond what the Correa bill proposes. What if web giant Google wants to apply and offers to pay the state the most money, he has said.
REVENUE FORECAST
Both sides tout online gambling's revenue potential for the recession-wracked state budget. But experts disagree about how much the state could get, and how soon.
Earlier this year, a study commissioned by the poker association estimated that legalized poker could earn the state more than $1 billion over the next decade.
But a 2010 study commissioned by the California Tribal Business Alliance concluded that online poker would yield little money to the state while voiding more lucrative revenue-shari