A few years ago at a barbecue I met woman who, when I asked the obligatory 'what do you do?' question, told me that she helped run one of Melbourne's biggest brothels.
Oh, I said, and asked polite questions about her line of work until, as any socially minded citizen would, I raised the thorny issue of drugs – weren't most of the women there to help pay for substance abuse of one form or another?
"You'd be surprised," she told me. "A lot of the girls don't even drink. But a lot of them gamble – plenty will take a couple of grand to the casino at the end of the night."
The women she described might be at a fairly extreme end of the gambling spectrum, but they are part of the "100,000 problem gamblers" Independent MP Andrew Wilkie aims to help with his plans to create a national gambling pre-commitment system, that would allow individuals to set limits on their addictive behaviour.
But Clubs Australia hit back yesterday at the National Press Club, with president Peter Newell announcing a $20 million marketing campaign against the Wilkie reforms.
Newell believes that the scheme will not work, pushing pokie players into buying black market 'smart cards' – the proposed means of tracking users' gambling spend Australia wide. Clubs Australia thinks pokie players will also migrate to other forms of gambling or set very high levels of 'pre-commitment' anyway. And, he says, it will kill off 11,500 jobs and strip $800 million from the NSW economy.
Wilkie was not impressed yesterday, holding a long press conference during which he said: "If Clubs Australia think they can intimidate me with the nonsense we heard today, then they misjudge me badly. If anything, I feel more committed to these reforms than I have ever have."
Senator Nick Xenophon joined Wilkie at the press conference to rather hyperbolically declare: "The poker machine lobby reminds me a bit like the slave owners of the 19th century in the United States, who say their whole way of life would be ruined if there were any changes bought about. That's how the industry is behaving."
This is a powerful political battle. On the one side, Wilkie gained support from the Gillard government to pursue the pre-commitment scheme in return for helping it form minority government. Further, he's armed with extensive research from the Productivity Commission, which estimates that seven lives of family or friends are seriously impacted by each problem gambler, with a national social cost of $4.7 billion a year.
On the other side, Clubs Australia knows that a rash of clubs closures will send strong anti-Labor ripples through the communities they service – clubs like the Rooty Hill RSL and Blacktown RSL, which both proved to be fruitful battlefields for Julia Gillard during the 2010 election campaign.
The debate looks utterly polarised: Wilkie was animated and resolute at yesterday's press conference. This is the single thing he wishes to get done. He already has the numbers to get the bill through the lower house, and though Nick Xenophon will no longer hold the balance of power in the Senate by the time the bill arrives, the Greens will – and they welcome the push.
So $20 million is about to be spent convincing the voting public that Labor is making a huge mistake. That might lead some to think Gillard will go back on her word and disappoint Wilkie.
However, the fire in Wilkie's eyes says this would be a big mistake. He has the power to scupper any part of the Gillard legislative agenda if he does not get his wish.
That's why the clash between Clubs Australia and the government looks like an unstoppable force meeting and immovable object. And that could produce a very loud bang indeed.
Registered: 2006/12/07 Posts: 0
The new policy is the brainchild of the new coalition government that was formed last October. Previous governments had enacted an online gambling ban, one which they had attempted to defend in the highest courts of the European Union. Many online gambling companies had attacked the ban, albeit unsuccessfully, in courts including the European Union Court of Justice.
According to government officials, one major reason behind lifting the ban is the fact that hundreds of thousands of Dutch citizens ignore the ban each year. By regulating the online gambling market, the Dutch government will be able to provide oversight, without taking away any activities that Dutch citizens currently enjoy.
"It is a big shift,” said Jaap Oosterveer, who spoke on behalf of the Dutch Ministry of Public Safety and Justice. “But this is a new government with a more liberal approach."
Of course, as with most governments who have been willing to regulate online gambling, the Dutch government does want to impose some measures on Internet gambling. For instance, the government plans to put safeguards in place that would help protect consumers against gambling addiction, fraud, and other potential hazards.
A regulated gambling market in the Netherlands would put their policies roughly in line with many other major European Nations. The United Kingdom, Sweden and Austria have regulated online gambling for some time, while France and Italy created regulatory schemes in 2010.
According to the Dutch government, regulations on online gambling may also prove to be quite lucrative for the Netherlands. According to their figures, Internet gambling and lottery licenses are likely to generate at least 10 million Euros a year starting in 2012.